11.19.26
Webinar | Exploring the SAFc Emissions Accounting and Reporting Guidelines V2.0
Recorded on November 19, 2026, the Sustainable Aviation Buyers Alliance (SABA) team from the Center for Green Market Activation and RMI walks through version 2.0 of the SAFc Emissions Accounting and Reporting Guidelines. The guidelines show companies how to account for and report sustainable aviation fuel (SAF) and SAF certificates (SAFc) in their climate disclosures.
Version 2.0 builds on the original 2022 guidelines. It reflects a maturing SAFc market and recent updates from the Science Based Targets initiative (SBTi), the GHG Protocol, and the AIM Platform.
A full transcript of the webinar is available below.
TRANSCRIPT
This transcript has been edited for clarity and readability.
ANDREW CHEN:
Hey folks, good morning, good afternoon, good day, wherever you may be. Thanks for joining us. We’ll give it just a second or two, as we—great to see almost 30 folks already online so far. We are really excited to be sharing some updates and some details on the version two of the SAFc accounting and reporting guidelines, just published on Monday. So kind of a little bit of a celebration today, as well as a chance to do some Q&A. So really excited to get some questions from folks.
As always, we will have the chat function going if you want to throw some questions in there. And please keep in mind, we will be setting aside quite a lot of time today to cover some questions. But I think with that, almost up to 40 folks, why don’t we get kicked off so that we make sure we save a lot of time for questions and getting into some details. And Alison, next slide, please.
So first of all, welcome and thanks for joining. I’m Andrew Chen. I’m a principal at RMI and I sit on the leadership team of SABA. I’ll be joined by some other colleagues today that we’ll talk about in a second here. But as I mentioned earlier, I have the pleasure of kicking us off today in our update on the progress in the SAFc ecosystem, but also to hand it over to some colleagues in the SABA team to talk about some more details about our version 2 update, some deep dives in terms of some additional detail that we think is important, and leaving quite a lot of ample space for next step conversations and Q&A. And with that, I will ask for the next slide, please.
So today I’m joined by a team across the Center for Green Market Activation and RMI. So we are the SABA team working on accounting reporting. And really want to give a big thanks to everyone on the call today, but especially the folks up here who are effectively the lead authors of the version 2 update and really helped get it out the door. But in addition to that, it’s a huge thank you to a lot of folks who are on the line today. It’s been a very collaborative process. We’ve really appreciated the input and support and conversation along the way. So I will be handing over to some different folks today, but we have Corey, Ethan, and Claire available in the team as well to help answer some questions after we hand over to Laura, and Laura hands over to Jackie, and we get into the Q&A.
Why don’t we go ahead and let me just try and get us warmed up for the conversation. So I’ll ask for the next slide. And just as a reminder of where the work sits: really building off the foundation that was started in 2022. And we’ll take a little look and conversation quickly on the evolution that we’ve seen in the SAFc landscape over the last couple of years, especially this most recent year. But version 1 was established to fill a number of important needs, and it’s been put into practice. And as that’s matured, the guidelines have needed to evolve. And that’s where we are now, is talking about our version 2. So speaking to that evolution, if I ask for the next slide, please.
Let’s talk about the progress we’ve seen in the SAFc ecosystem, really digging into the last year specifically. So we’ll go into the next slide. We’ve seen a lot of updates. And since 2022 in general, there’s been quite a lot that’s happened as the SAF certificate concept has grown and the rest of the ecosystem has continued to develop around it as well. So we’re here today in, you know, near the end of 2026, and there’s still more work that we’re looking at in the future in terms of the Science Based Targets initiative, Greenhouse Gas Protocol. But this last year has been incredibly important, and I think quite monumental. We’ll dig into that. Let’s look at the next slide, please.
So we’ve seen some big things and some important updates across a number of key cross-sectoral standards and bodies, including SBTi, Greenhouse Gas Protocol, and AIM. So we’ve got the Corporate Net Zero Standard Version 2.0 of SBTi, the update to the Greenhouse Gas Protocol, and the publication of the AIM Platform Standard and Guidance. So all really important pieces of the puzzle to help provide the transparency, the rigor, the credibility that’s necessary in the system here. And if we go into the next slide.
We can also talk a little bit about how SAFc and the demand for SAF certificates in general, and the market for it, has been growing quite a lot over the last years, and especially if we compare ourselves to 2022. If I just focus in on the SAFc registry alone, as one place where we are obviously closely involved and tracking the market activity, we’re looking at possibly our largest ever month right now, as of the 19th of November. And our largest month previously has been, I think, about 42,000 tons of SAF certificates issued on the registry in a month. We think we might break that this month. So there have definitely been some fantastic increases, and we’ve been really encouraged by seeing the growth across both the SAF certificate ecosystem as well as the market itself. You know, we’ve seen a lot of options on how to buy. We’ve seen a lot more interest from buyers, and we’ve seen quite a lot more uptake. So it’s been fantastic. And thanks, everyone, for your activity and support in the market. Maybe one last slide, please.
And just as a little bit of a reminder before I hand over to Laura here about the scope of the guidelines that we’re talking about today, and the version 2 of it. So really just keeping in mind on the bottom here what’s in scope for the guidelines, and continues to be a guiding principle for our work here, is how companies account for and report their SAF and their SAF certificate emissions in their climate disclosures, especially for voluntary. And what’s out of scope is really detailed SAF certificate quality criteria, registry rules and functions, SAF that’s used towards regulatory compliance. These are not necessarily in scope of the guidance. So I want to keep that in mind as we get into our more detailed update, and I hand over to my colleague Laura Hutchinson.
LAURA HUTCHINSON:
Thanks, Andrew. I’ll take us through some structural considerations for the document, just orienting folks who may not have had a chance to look at it, and also give you a bit of detail as to kind of what’s in here, what’s new, and why. So if we can progress to the next slide.
So the version 2 guidelines, of course, build on version 1, which was released in 2022. But we’ve learned a lot about the SAF market, about SAF certificate mechanisms. The infrastructure has grown considerably, and companies have gained more and more experience using these tools in the context of an evolving cross-sectoral standards ecosystem in that time. So the version 2 of guidelines really does—attempts to take all of those lessons learned and that contextual shift into account to make sure that this is a comprehensive resource for companies that can support really credible climate disclosure and action now.
So some key areas that were focus areas for us in the revision were, first and foremost, adding new personas, or new roles in the aviation value chain that participate in this ecosystem; clarifying what their roles are, what their aviation emissions accounting practices look like, and how they integrate with the SAFc ecosystem. So the personas that we added here are airports, aircraft lessors, financial institutions, travel management companies, and original equipment manufacturers, or OEMs. Structurally, the guidelines organize some of these roles into broader categories. So, for example, all aircraft operators are nested under one broader persona, inclusive of airlines, carriers from a freight perspective, and private jets. And noting that travel management companies are grouped with freight forwarders or logistics providers under a broader category there as well.
The other area that we focused deeply in the revision on is enhancing the technical guidance and enhancing the level of detail of granularity of the recommendations that are provided, in line with that evolving ecosystem for standards, and in line with much of the development in knowledge in the SAF certificate ecosystem specifically as well. One of the biggest changes, or additions to the document, includes a new accounting approach, which we call substitution, which kind of sits as an option alongside the emissions reduction option. These are framed throughout the document as Option A and Option B. We’ll come back to this in more detail in a few slides here.
The other thing that’s clarified, which is consistent with version one but further emphasized here, in line with the SBTi Corporate Net Zero Standard and the aviation sector guidance, is that throughout, a well-to-wake, or full life cycle assessment, boundary is applied for the emissions accounting approach as well as the SAFc emissions accounting approach, just for consistency. And then finally, the document includes much more detail than previously on co-claiming, and specifically clarifying details and guardrails for co-claiming across different Scope 3 claimants.
Finally, the document takes a really specific view to making sure that this document is aligned with broader developments in the ecosystem. So as Andrew emphasized, it really focuses on aligning the guidance, the recommendations in this document, with ongoing developments from broader standard setters, such as the Greenhouse Gas Protocol, the Science Based Targets initiative, the Advanced and Indirect Mitigation Platform, and other key frameworks. It also, as an additional component that is distinct from version one, clarifies further how this document can be audited against. Specifically, there is an appendix that includes key audit evidence assurance parameters, and the language throughout is clarified to support auditability. And then finally, there is a bunch of reference content, which isn’t core to the subject matter of this document but can help as a reference point for content such as sustainability characteristics, registry criteria, and some other topics as they relate to accounting and reporting practices. Next slide, please.
Great. So how is the document structured? You will find that there is an introductory section, which attempts to introduce and clarify some of the key concepts that apply to each of the personas throughout the document. There is a big chunk which divides persona by persona into recommendations that apply to each of these aviation sector roles. And then there is some supporting appendices that relate to that main body content.
The introduction really is key in introducing some of the basics. What is SAF? What is a SAF certificate? How do you establish a SAF emissions profile? What is life cycle assessment? What is corporate aviation emissions accounting? How does that work? What is SAFc emissions accounting and reporting? And what are the different methods? How does it all build together? And then finally, a section on co-claiming as well. These are really critical in kind of establishing the context for some of the recommendations that are provided in each of the personas.
Within the personas, each includes considerations for emissions accounting, so actually accounting for aviation emissions in any of these entities’ physical emissions inventory; to, when it is applicable, it includes quite a bit of detail on how to account for SAF certificate emissions outcomes; and then also includes reporting considerations for both SAF and SAFc where applicable. It also points to some of the other personas where they apply. For example, for any given company that plays a role in the aviation value chain, their own employee business travel activity would point to the air transport customer persona, as opposed to being fundamentally defined within, say, the OEM persona.
And then finally, the appendices cover kind of a reference set of topics that can support broader understanding of how the accounting and reporting best practices that are laid out in this document get applied in context of, say, broader sustainability criteria, registry function, things of that nature. Next slide, please.
Great. So this document covers, as I emphasized, a number of different personas, or different aviation value chain participants, and we included several new roles in this expanded document, including travel management companies, airports, aircraft lessors, financial institutions, and OEMs. Next slide, please.
And within each of the persona structures, there’s quite a bit of detail about what the persona is, what their roles in the aviation value chain are, how they should proceed with their aviation emissions accounting in the context of that persona: so identifying their emissions sources, identifying the right calculation approaches, selecting their activity data and appropriate emissions factors, actually applying that calculation, and aggregating and rolling up to the corporate level.
The SAFc accounting section within each of these personas, as applicable, includes two different options for accounting for SAF certificate emissions outcomes: one being calculating the outcomes as an emissions reduction, which is consistent with the approach that was in V1, or as a substitution into a market-based inventory, which is the new approach that’s proposed here. Both of these details—or both of these proposed options—are elaborated in detail in each of the personas. And then finally, the SAFc reporting section in each covers what to report, what of that is really core, is audit or documentation versus public disclosure, and then considerations for co-claiming. Next slide, please.
So, as emphasized prior, the emissions accounting section, which is really focused on establishing what a company’s physical emissions inventory for their aviation emission sources looks like, goes through selecting a calculation approach, which is typically either fuel-based, distance-based, or spend-based. It provides specific recommendations based on each of the personas, goes through specific recommendations for collecting activity data and identifying appropriate emissions factors that’s consistent with that calculation approach, and then articulates how to apply that calculation.
Here I’ll emphasize that really all that’s represented in the guidelines is a synthesis of best practices that exist in this space. This is already something that companies know how to do. What is reflected here is simply kind of a synthesis of best practices, for example from the GLEC Framework and other references, that are kind of the key best-in-class emissions accounting approaches as defined by third parties. So these are really reference materials, as opposed to core recommendations of this document. Next slide.
And then the remainder of these personas, as I emphasized, covers how to calculate those SAF certificate emissions outcomes, either as an emissions reduction or with the substitution method, and substituting that into a total market-based emissions inventory calculation, and goes through each of these step by step. We’ll talk through these in a future slide. All right, let’s move forward.
Wonderful. So let’s go into detail into this reduction versus substitution approach, and in particular interrogate what the difference is between these two accounting approaches are, noting that they’re both equal options as presented in this document. Next slide, please.
Great. So again, before we get into some of the details of the calculation approach, at a top level, this is where we’re coming from and where we’re going with this addition of a proposed calculation approach that’s distinct from the emissions reduction approach, which is represented in V1.
When we wrote the initial guidelines in 2022, the recommendation was fairly simple within the guidelines, and looked to maintain as much consistency as possible with both the Greenhouse Gas Protocol and the Science Based Targets initiative at the time, which did not reference the use of market instruments beyond Scope 2 in detail, and to align as best we could with best-in-class product standards, such as CORSIA, for determining the SAF LCA. The approach then was to really lean into calculating simply the emissions reduction associated with any given volume of SAF. And that remains a valid approach to calculating and disclosing these emissions outcomes. And the V1 really focused on that simplicity and didn’t clarify necessarily the reporting approach that should go alongside that. Really kept this at—how would you credibly calculate these emissions outcomes, and how do they relate to your quantified physical inventory aviation emissions?
Now, looking forward four years later in V2, we know a lot more. We’ve had experience adopting these things. And we have the benefit of understanding how SBTi is moving forward and GHGP is moving forward in their actions and market instruments framework. And we have the benefit of being able to build on top of the AIM Standards framework for understanding how to relate market instruments and actions to a company’s physical emissions inventory, and make sure that those instruments that are supported are truly associated with that value chain activity.
So V2 really builds on that broader spectrum here by clarifying that, in order to be used to substantiate an associated with value chain claim or use case, SAFc alone cannot substantiate a claim inside of the physical emissions inventory, but rather needs to be reported separately, alongside. There are two options for how to do this, to make sure that those emissions outcomes function in relation to a company’s physical aviation emissions but are reported separately: either Option A, by calculating that emissions reduction in an impact statement, or using Option B, with the substitution approach in a market-based inventory. Again, both are equivalent here.
And then further, to make sure that these emissions outcomes can be used in association with a company’s value chain emissions, the guidelines include checks to assure that these emissions outcomes don’t exceed the amount of physical inventory activity in order to retain that claim. Again, this is all building from the evolving standards landscape, in line with GHG Protocol, AIM, and TCAT as well, to some degree.
Of course, some of these broader standards are still in development, and specifically the Greenhouse Gas Protocol Actions and Market Instruments standard, as part of their consolidated corporate standard effort, is still in draft. And that first draft is expected in the end of next year, and we don’t expect that standard to be finalized by 2028. So all of these recommendations kind of exist in an evolving environment. But we feel confident that what is reflected in V2 is the best that we—the best that we have, and a really solid set of recommendations on a better foundation than we were in the context of V1. Next slide, please.
So, just briefly going into the details of these two calculation approaches. First, with the emissions reduction option, Option A. This again was reflected in version one. This is simply calculating the emissions reduction associated with any given volume of SAF as compared to a conventional jet fuel comparator. This reduction is reported in an impact statement as a negative amount of CO2 equivalent, right? So the emissions reduction calculated as a function of the amount of SAF and the difference between the conventional jet fuel and SAF carbon intensities. This is a simple approach. It’s reflected in life cycle assessment methodologies that are best practice today for sustainable aviation fuel, and it’s consistent with what’s in V1.
The additional component that has been added in this Option A approach in the guidelines is that additional check to ensure that these outcomes are associated with value chain from a quantification standpoint. So it’s what’s called emissions matching in the AIM standard, ensuring that companies are checking for the maximum amount of emissions reductions that they can apply to any given amount of aviation activity in their value chain. So you’ll see this as an additional part in each of those personas, as an additional calculation to make sure that when using this approach, you’re still making sure that you’re only addressing aviation emissions to the extent that the SAF can decarbonize your existing physical supply chain emissions.
Now moving over to Option B, or the substitution approach, which is the new one that’s presented in this document. This is an approach that resembles the approach for disclosing electricity emissions in Scope 2 in the market-based mechanisms, and is represented in the actions and market instruments work within Greenhouse Gas Protocol, and the AIM standard, and various other places. So this is suggested as—as a way to align with that accounting approach as it—as it applies to Scope 3 and Scope 1.
This uses the—just the emissions intensity of the—of SAF as the basis for emissions accounting and reporting, and fundamentally just substitutes that emissions factor in for your aviation emissions activity. This often requires, in most cases, a conversion factor, so converting that SAF volume and that SAF emissions factor into whatever your aviation emissions activity data looks like in your inventory. So whether that’s passenger kilometers or ton kilometers or other units, depending on the persona. All of this is spelled out in the guidelines. There’s a conversion, and then you substitute in, making sure that those units are consistent.
Again, this is consistent with an approach that’s increasingly common in broader cross-sectoral standards and guidance for attributional market instruments, of which SAFc is one. And so we wanted to be able to present this as an option, given that that is an option in some of these broader standards as well.
One benefit of this approach is that it has the potential to be more precise for categories where you’re accounting for emissions outcomes across multiple scopes and categories. So specifically thinking about air transport operators that account for their aviation emissions—and, as an extension, their SAF certificate emissions outcomes and SAF emissions outcomes—split between Scope 3 Category 3 and Scope 1. So the emissions factor kind of substitution approach is slightly more accurate in that use case in particular.
Another benefit of this approach is that, because you’re substituting in a quantity and emissions factor, it inherently mitigates over-accounting for emissions outcomes. So here you don’t have to do that kind of maximum—how much can I address with this approach?—a check like you have to do with Option A.
One final note here. In previous versions of the version two draft that we’d circulated, including in the public consultation version, Option A was previously referred to as the subtraction approach. So just noting that this has been reframed in the final version as a reduction approach. Next slide.
Okay. Finally, so we went through the accounting approach. How does that get reported, right? The approach that is becoming commonplace here across the Greenhouse Gas Protocol, referenced by the Science Based Targets initiative, as documented in the AIM Platform standard, and as documented in the TCAT standard, is a multi-statement reporting structure, where you have the physical inventory alongside any additional supplementary statements. So the typical approach that’s proposed in most of these frameworks is that physical inventory, statement one. There’s a market-based or contractual inventory as the second statement. And then there’s an impact statement as—as the third statement here. And then potentially beyond value chain and other indicators can be separate from that.
So just referencing the previous accounting approaches into this multi-statement framework: Option A, the reduction approach, is consistent with statement three, so any calculated emissions reductions would be reported in an impact statement. And any substituted approaches leveraging Option B would be reflected in a market-based inventory.
Wonderful. I believe I’m passing to Jackie.
JACKIE BREW:
Yes. Thank you, Laura. And we have just one final topic before closing out and opening it up for Q&A, and that is on co-claiming. So Alison, if you wouldn’t mind moving to the next slide.
Co-claiming builds off of the Greenhouse Gas Protocol methodology, where one company will be reporting an emission and emitting activity within its Scope 1 inventory, while multiple other organizations could be reporting those same emissions within different Scope 3 categories. And so co-claiming builds off that same concept, where multiple entities can claim the outcomes of the same quantity of SAF or SAF certificate without it being considered erroneous double counting, which would be when stakeholders who are in the same value chain role or layer are erroneously claiming the same SAF certificate.
And this concept is not new to these V2 guidelines. In particular, in both the V1 guidelines and what is very common in the SAFc market today is where an aircraft operator will claim the Scope 1 and Scope 3 Category 3 portion of a certificate, while an air transport customer will, if it’s a business traveler, claim the Scope 3 Category 6, or, if it’s a corporate shipper, claim the Scope 3 Category 4. What is newer in both these guidelines, and has been a topic within the industry within 2026, is co-claiming across multiple different Scope 3 companies.
So if you look at the diagram on the bottom of the slide, the first two columns on the left either just have a corporate jet claiming, being the sole claimant, or an airline and a passenger—a corporate traveler—being the two co-claimants. But the two verticals on the right show some examples where multiple of the personas who were outlined in these guidelines can be co-claiming with one another. So in the third column, you have the airline, a travel management company, and a corporate passenger, each claiming the same certificate. And then, using a shipping example, you could have the airline, a freight forwarder, a corporate shipper, and an OEM.
And we think that co-claiming can be a really valuable tool to help scale the SAF market at a time that will be critical to ensuring that their SAF production will continue to grow. It can help by reducing the premium, which can help existing buyers buy more. It can help bring in new buyers, of which the SAF premium was previously a barrier. And it can also help highlight the types of organizations, other than airlines and air transport customers, who can invest in SAF certificates to help grow the market as well as address their aviation emissions.
However, book and claim is already a complex topic. Co-claiming makes it even more complex. And care will need to be taken to ensure that, one, co-claiming is a tool that can be used to really scale the market, rather than just reducing the premium for existing buyers to co-claim with one another; and that it does not lead to actual or the perception of double counting. Which is why it’s going to be really important for these early examples of co-claiming to be strong demonstrators of how it can expand the buyer pool and can do so without double counting. So, Laura, if you want—not Laura, sorry. Alison, if you want to move to the next slide.
For companies who are looking to co-claim, the guidelines outline three criteria that should be met. And these criteria are drawn from the AIM Standard, which was released earlier this year, but updated to be specific towards the aviation sector.
So, first, each co-claimant should report the aviation emissions in its physical inventory for the layer that they’re looking to co-claim against. So, as an example, if an OEM wants to use SAF certificates to address the emissions associated with the use of its sold products, they should already be reporting those emissions in Scope 3 Category 11 that they’re looking to claim the certificates against.
Second, each claim should reflect a distinct value chain layer within the same aviation use case. So, as an example, you wouldn’t want two business travelers to be co-claiming with each other because they’re the same role. They wouldn’t be reporting the same gallon of SAF, so they shouldn’t be claiming the same SAF certificate.
And then, combined, the layers looking to co-claim with one another should represent real functional steps in a real-world value chain. So a freight forwarder and a corporate shipper could be co-claiming together, as they are typical functional steps within a value chain. But it wouldn’t make sense for a freight forwarder and a business traveler to be co-claiming together, because they wouldn’t be entities within each other’s traditional physical value chain. And Section 1.4 of the guidelines goes into more examples of when all three criteria are or are not met.
Once entities have identified or parties that they meet all of those criteria, they will want to demonstrate that they have a unique right to report the SAF certificate through the agreement or contract with the supplier on how the co-claims can be co-claimed and tracked, with safeguards against preventing any sort of double counting, and the SAF certificate retired in their name. And again, 1.4 is the section where most of the co-claiming content is listed.
With that, Alison, if you want to go forward two slides. We just wanted to close out the slide portion of this webinar with, one, once again thanking everyone who has provided input throughout this revision process. We’re really excited about the new personas and entities who are represented in the guidelines, and that, of course, wouldn’t have been possible without organizations from those different groups providing their feedback. So thank you very much for everyone who contributed to these revisions.
Second, if you haven’t done so already, we really encourage you to download, review, as well as share the guidelines. They’re going to be most impactful if they are used by a wide audience.
And then finally, now is the time to invest in SAF certificates. As Andrew had mentioned, 2026 has been a really exciting year for the book and claim and SAF space, with key updated materials from SBTi, GHGP. And then we aim for these guidelines to be a complement to those tools as well, that should really give companies the confidence that they can go purchase SAF certificates and credibly account and report for them. So if you were waiting to buy for the first time or to buy more, we think now is a great time to do so. And we’re hoping that 2027 can be a great, great year of growth for the SAF market.
With that, we want to open it up to all of you for Q&A. There’s a few questions in the chat that we can start with, but then, yeah, please, please share more if you have them.
And I’m happy, Laura, to take this first one, as it relates to co-claiming, which was just covering. How does this co-claiming workstream interact with the co-claiming workstream from RSB? So there is a group called Co-Claims for Shared Action being led by RSB, SFC, and MIT, who has been conducting some co-claiming pilots this year and are due to release a draft framework at Aviation Carbon in a couple of weeks. We have been attending the different working groups that they have had on co-claiming at different aviation conferences throughout the year. Laura will be going to Aviation Carbon in London, and we are eager and excited to review the draft framework and provide feedback. We know that everyone involved in both of these groups would love to work towards making sure there are consistent criteria for co-claiming that can give the market needed clarity. And so, through pilots being conducted by different groups, we’re going to be working towards that.
All right, let’s see. So there is a question about mixing attributional and consequential accounting in the LCA, noting that these guidelines include—are primarily an attributional LCA approach, but also include indirect land use change, or ILUC, emissions, which are fundamentally consequential. What is the logic for combining these? Laura, do you want to take this one?
LAURA HUTCHINSON:
Sure. And this is one of the complexities of SAF and best practices: juggling, on one hand, some of the, you know, purist accounting desires to keep attributional and consequential dimensions of accounting fundamentally separate for different purposes, recognizing that they do typically see problems in different lights; and on the other, trying to make sure that, to the extent that we’re calculating the emissions value and profile of the sustainable aviation fuel, we do so comprehensively and consider its broader potential effects.
So specifically—and most of you in the aviation sector are all over this, right?—the CORSIA methodology for SAF calculates both core LCA value, from an attributional standpoint, where you’re adding up all of the bits of the life cycle of the SAF from feedstock collection all the way through to the production and delivery of the fuel. But also there’s an additional component that’s added that is a consequential assessment. That’s the induced land use change value, which looks at what the impacts of the fuel are from a broader standpoint. You could argue that that is simply kind of extending the system boundary, which is more of an attributional concept. But really, this has become best practice in the aviation industry to either consider ILUC, as CORSIA does, as part of the core emissions calculation, or to consider some of those effects in another way, by kind of really kind of looking at a subset of feedstocks that have low to no ILUC risk as the scope of what can be certified under a scheme, right?
So while we recognize that the CORSIA approach to SAF LCA calculation in particular is not kind of a purist attributional approach to calculation, we also recognize that some of the components in life cycle assessment calculations under EU-RED and some of these other schemes aren’t purely attributional either. And I think the approach that we’ve taken in the guidelines is, one, in alignment with the AIM standard and with aviation best practices here, recommend not cutting some of these elements of the life cycle assessment out arbitrarily just because they happen to not be purely attributional, but rather making sure that the accounting approach is consistent with attribution or consequential principles, making a distinction on that basis.
Ultimately, Greenhouse Gas Protocol will be the arbiter of what goes where, and to what extent we have to be really diligent about what gets called attribution or consequential, and how much that determines what gets reported in what bucket. But for now, our recommendation is to take an approach where we’re fully recognizing what’s being captured in the certification of the LCA itself, and applying that as best you can to either attributional or consequential principles in disclosure.
JACKIE BREW:
Thanks, Laura. And I think another one that will be helpful for you to address: When we say outcomes don’t exceed physical inventory activity, how do we define physical inventory beyond by activity? For example, do we define by regional inventory, carrier inventory, et cetera?
LAURA HUTCHINSON:
Yeah, this is a great question. So maybe the best way to answer this question is through an example. The restriction on kind of making sure that you’re only addressing your physical inventory activity is defined by what you’re trying to address with SAF certificates, right? So if I’m a company that has a bunch of different types of aviation emissions, but I’m looking to specifically address my business travel emissions, then that would be the cap. Then that would be kind of the restriction of the aviation emissions I’m looking to address. If I’m looking to address the entirety of my aviation emissions, then that can move across categories and effectively aggregate across all of your exposure to aviation emissions in your inventory.
So it depends on the company’s intent, whether or not they’re co-claiming and identifying a specific layer for which specific SAF certificates are tagged, to make sure that that’s consistent with who they’re co-claiming with, things of that nature. But in general, it’s kind of bounded by how—you know, which emissions, which activities that generate emissions are you looking to address. And that’s your boundary.
JACKIE BREW:
Great. Thank you, Laura. And we have one other question in the chat as of right now, so if anyone has any others, feel free to pop them in. Do the buyers of physical SAF for which the SAF certificate has been sold still get to make the lower location-based Statement 1 emissions claim? If not, then does the lower location-based claim just vanish, given that the SAFc buyer cannot make the location-based claim?
LAURA HUTCHINSON:
Yeah, another good question. So when SAF certificates are purchased separately from the physical product, there are a bunch of different scenarios at play here. So let’s assume that a fuel provider is the SAF certificate producer, and they’re selling effectively conventional aviation fuel to an airline, selling everything as SAF certificates. All of those attributes are turning into SAF certificates. None of this is bundled. In that case, you know, the way to mitigate that double counting risk is in effect selling the conventional—the physical conventional jet fuel as conventional and not attaching those attributes. So, you know, that’s maybe a simple case.
Another more complex case is if a fuel producer is selling physical SAF with those attributes intact to an air transport provider, and selling SAF certificates to a customer of aviation services as unbundled. In that case, it’s important to mitigate what the airline can sell or can claim to their physical customers to avoid double counting in that same value chain layer. So, you know, this is really scenario by scenario. Encourage folks to look at that co-claiming section in the guidelines that articulates where and how co-claiming can occur, where those double counting risks can occur. And in particular, in the air transport operator persona section, there are some considerations for how an air transport operator that’s consuming physical SAF might adopt some kind of common sense transparency practices to mitigate their customers’ double claiming risk, in effect.
JACKIE BREW:
Thanks, Laura. And we got another one, which I’ll take to start, but feel free to pile on, which is a good question. How is the max blending limit of 50% impacting the physical inventory claim limit? I.e., can a business traveler reduce their emissions by more than 85% times 50%?
So this is a good question. And, you know, assuming that the 85% represents the 85% carbon intensity reduction of the neat SAF. And the way these V2 guidelines are currently written is that you could go up to the carbon intensity reduction of the SAF. So we would say that you would, if you were, be able to reduce your emissions by 85%. The blending limit of 50% is a good question that may need to be considered going forward, as that becomes—moves from a theoretical to a real physical limit. But given that SAF today is less than 1% of the jet fuel mix, as of right now, it’s just referring to the carbon intensity reduction potential of the SAF. Laura, anything else you’d add?
LAURA HUTCHINSON:
Maybe I’d add that that’s also consistent with how the AIM standard and guidance treats this issue. While it’s important to consider kind of the physical implementation limits on some of these interventions, including SAF deployment, we and the AIM standard considers this SAF example as an exemption to that, in that kind of any given volume of SAF is indeed displacing conventional jet fuel. We’re not being limited by kind of whether or not it’s being used on any given aircraft in this case, right? So while a maximum blending limit for many, many SAFs today is 50%, but practically they’re blended at lower percentage rates, we do not, again, at this time consider—and the AIM standard does not consider at this time—that blending limit to be an additional restriction.
JACKIE BREW:
All right. Well, I think that brings us to the end of the questions in the chat. Thank you very much, everyone, for joining today, sharing the questions, and once again, for everyone who contributed to the development of the guidelines. Again, call to action: review, share, and buy SAF. And yeah, let us know if there’s anything we can do to support you all. So thank you all for joining.
ANDREW CHEN:
Thanks, everyone.