11.10.26
Webinar | GMA Trucking Education Workshop 2
In this second session of GMA Trucking’s carrier education series, recorded on November 10, 2026, the GMA team explains ZETc generation, data and reporting requirements, roles of carriers and CPOs, and lessons learned from GMA Trucking RFP I.
A full transcript of the webinar is available below. Presentation slides can be accessed here.
The following transcript has been edited for legibility and clarity.
JAKOB SANCHEZ:
Good morning, good afternoon, and thank you, everyone, for joining us for the second installment in our carrier education workshop series, titled “How to Participate in the GMA Trucking Ecosystem.” I’m joined today by my colleagues Andre de Fontaine, Clayton Gerber, and Stacey McCluskey. My name is Jakob Sanchez, and I will be taking us through the first part of today’s discussion.
Just a reminder of where we are in the timeline. For those that were unable to attend or would like to revisit the materials from Workshop One, we covered keystone topics such as what is GHG accounting, the fundamentals of book and claim, and GMA Trucking 101. Those materials, the recording, transcript, and presentation materials can be found on the GMA Trucking website.
Today, in Workshop Two, we’re going to be diving in a bit deeper into the practical considerations for how to participate in GMA Trucking procurements, roles and responsibilities, and where to begin.
And our third workshop, which will be held in the middle of December, registration for that is now live. We’ll be covering topics even deeper around additionality, allocation and claims, double counting, and the results. The results of the RFI, so if we receive any questions today that fall into one of those buckets, we might just flag those and push till that third workshop series.
So for today, we’re going to be covering the key lessons and takeaways from the first procurement. We’re going to spend some time going through the mechanics and data requirements for ZETc generation, then we’ll go to considerations for renewable energy procurement and matching, what’s new and to look forward for in the second procurement, some next steps, and there will be plenty of time at the end for Q&A.
So please, throughout today’s session, drop your questions into the chat. We will prioritize answering those at the end. And any that we don’t get around to, we can either save for that third workshop or take them offline and answer one on one.
So with that framing in mind, let’s dive into the lessons learned from the pilot procurement. And I’m going to frame this conversation around everything that needs to be known for our upcoming procurement as well.
But the basic bid criteria to participate in the RFP is that the carrier must operate a Class 8 electric truck that is backed by 100% renewable energy. And these services must comply with the principle of regulatory surplus, so going beyond any emissions reductions required by law.
And within the bid packet that was requested from the carriers, we asked for the price per unit of activity, fleet size, freight work, operation category and duty cycle, the status of the assets, a financial history, and operating history.
The GMA Trucking RFP ecosystem revolves around the carrier. And the carrier is the linchpin that operates with all of the interested parties. So the carrier is going to bilaterally work with the OEMs, CPOs and infrastructure providers, physical service recipients, and the offtakers of the environmental attributes, either through the GMA Trucking membership or contracted separately.
For the RFP responses that were received, the most successful and the ones that moved on were able to demonstrate competitive pricing, volume, demand, and proof of executability.
So the three main criteria that the shortlisted carriers were evaluated on were that ZETc pricing—that’s the price per unit of transport activity. They were able to align the response volume to the demand from our members; this reduces the need to reconfigure bids or select multiple carriers. And they were able to demonstrate that the bid was high quality and feasible, demonstrating executable project timelines grounded in real technology and duty cycles. They were able to demand forecast and a gauge for price visibility.
So of those 36 distinct bids, 15 were moved on to the shortlisting phase, where we conducted our due diligence and third-party evaluation. And then ultimately we selected a winner.
And the winner of the first procurement was Nevoya. Nevoya was able to deliver the lowest-priced attribute with the most closely matched volume. Importantly, they were able to demonstrate that they were able to be flexible with the GMA Trucking member demand. And they provided a highly detailed proposal with supporting documentation that greatly enabled a degree of quality assurance and verification on the project’s executability.
And the result of the Nevoya bid was a deployment of 63 Class 8 battery electric vehicles and brand-new DC fast charging infrastructure in Texas—the largest known deployment of ZEVs in the state. So this first procurement demonstrated really meaningful initial scale and proof of concept, and has laid the foundation for larger, more ambitious, and broader future deployments. And as we move into the Procurement II phase, we are definitely looking to expand on the success of our pilot procurement.
So to summarize the key takeaways for carriers looking to improve the competitiveness of their bids:
We want to right-size the opportunity. That means matching the deployment to the prospective buyer demand, and showing the project’s ability to scale up or down, depending on what the final demand and portfolio selection ends up being.
Submitting a competitive price. Explaining the costs, major assumptions, and financing terms that go into the actual certificate premium.
Reducing, wherever possible, execution uncertainty. This can come in the form of providing evidence that you have access to vehicles, site control, you are working with charging partners, sophisticated utility engagement, financing partners and leasing terms, and an achievable and deployable schedule to actually begin delivering on the assets.
And all of these lead into bringing a real project. So anchoring the bid in identifiable freight, a realistic duty cycle, and a realistic and credible charging plan.
All four of these are underscored by the ability to substantiate and evidence that through data. The underpinning of the RFP ecosystem is high-quality and high-fidelity data. So the ability to demonstrate energy use, evidence activity, prove that renewable energy is being purchased and retired accurately and allocated accurately, attribute ownership, and that any double counting controls are being managed and tracked. All of these five are going to greatly improve the bid competitiveness by reducing uncertainty on the GMA team and the third-party verification process.
So now we’re going to spend some time talking about what it actually is that we’re trading, and what the attribute is that the carriers are minting.
So a ZETc, or a zero emission trucking certificate, represents the transferable and fungible environmental attribute associated with eligible zero emission trucking activity. This is not the actual physical service that is delivered by the carrier to the physical recipient. This is the unbundled attribute that can then be sold and transferred.
ZETc can be transferred to a physical recipient at the time of physical delivery, but it does not have to be. And for our GMA Trucking membership, this is most of the time going to fall into the unbundled category.
So, once a carrier completes eligible trucking activity, they upload that data into a registry where the ZETc is then minted and issued, after which point it can be transferred and retired by buyers so that they can account for the environmental benefits of that trucking activity within their accounting frameworks.
And depending on the information that is available and the pathway that is selected, ZETcs can be quantified and traded in units of freight activity—tonne-kilometers, or TKM—or on energy consumption—kilowatt-hour electricity consumption. And this is all going to be based on the verified carrier operational data.
So, within those two big categories, energy-based and freight work-based, these two approaches both are able to generate ZETc.
For the energy-based, it’s going to be the total energy consumption, including losses from upstream transmission and distribution and any charger-to-vehicle losses, times the emissions intensity of that electric service. So, this is where the emissions reflects the well-to-tank emissions of the energy delivered into the vehicle, plus the operational efficiency of that actual vehicle.
As opposed to the freight work-based pathway, this is going to be freight mass times distance, or that TKM figure, times an emissions intensity. And where the emissions intensity for freight work, that reflects the well-to-wheel emissions per TKM for a given vehicle class and category.
We can think of the energy-based pathway as being bottom-up, starting from the electricity delivered, versus the freight work-based, which we can think of as being more top-down, starting at the cargo that is actually loaded onto the vehicle.
So issuing a ZETc, as I stated, starts with reliable operational records. So where do we actually pull that data from?
For kilowatt-hour consumption, data sources can include truck telematics, information from your charging provider, or CMS receipts.
And the emissions intensity of the electricity can be pulled from a variety of sources. It can be from a database such as GLEC or EcoInvent. It can be evidenced by on-site generation or behind-the-meter solar or wind, or a generation such as that. And it can be offset using purchased renewable energy certificates, such as those that might be bundled with a power purchase agreement.
It’s important to note that the emissions intensity, no matter which pathway you select, must include all losses, including T&D and power generation infrastructure. This allows us to create a full, well-to-wheel lifecycle assessment for the actual emissions of that electricity.
For our freight work pathway, we’re going to use those same sources for kilowatt-hour consumption and the electricity emissions intensity. We’ll still need these because, as noted, the electric vehicles must be backed by 100% renewable energy. So we’re going to need this information in order to offset that electricity consumption.
For the freight mass, this can come from a TMS system, bill of lading, carrier invoices, written attestation, or model data.
With freight mass and with kilowatt-hour consumption, no moves or activity by the vehicle can go unallocated. This means that any empty backhauls, driving between customers, or activity of the truck that would otherwise not be attributed to a specific customer must be included in that information, so that all of the information can be correctly allocated across all the activity of that vehicle.
And for distance, similarly, this can come from the transport management system or within the cab’s telematics.
So, having covered the essential data requirements for both pathways, I’m going to hand it off to my colleague Clayton Gerber to walk through some of the specifics of how these pathways interact with our first procurement versus our second procurement.
CLAYTON GERBER:
Thanks so much, Jakob. And quickly, I’ll also note that there’s a lot more data on these kinds of accounting rules and measurement components. All this is adhering to the GLEC Framework or the ISO 14083. So, there’s a large ecosystem for emissions accounting that we can leverage and share more details as we get into the implementation into the RFP itself.
I’ll note here that the next procurement does take a slightly different approach on the ZETc issuance. And so, in our first approach, in our first procurement process, we required the freight work as the key and only functional unit.
The broader context right now is that the Smart Freight Centre Market-Based Measures framework, which is one of the guiding documents in the ecosystem that we leverage to back and justify this ZETc market, is under revision right now. And it’s currently going through the first draft that will be out for public consultation soon. But one of the impending updates to that is this energy-based approach, where we can focus a little bit more on the fuel—the megajoules, or the kilowatt-hours in this case—to be able to help streamline the issuance process on the side of the carriers.
And so, in this case, we’re going to be open to both pathways. If there’s anything that changes in the MBM from now until the final publication, obviously, we’ll update this as needed before the RFP. But the going approach is going to be to enable both the energy-based and the freight work, depending on what companies and what carriers have access to.
If those are already reporting freight work, this is obviously going to be something that we will still want to be able to have for the issuance process, to be able to have full transparency. But we also recognize that, if you’re doing LTL operations, for example, getting accurate freight payload per every single shipment and every single leg of your shipment can be challenging, and may not necessarily be feasible to get that kind of primary data on every load.
And so, I’ll note here that while the energy-based approach does not necessarily need freight work for the actual issuance of the certificate, that kind of information and the distribution of what’s loaded and unloaded is still going to be important for carriers who are looking to provide attributes to physical customers as well. Again, feel free to drop questions in the chat if anything comes to mind here.
But as Jakob had alluded to as well, empty journeys have to be allocated to all of those shippers who are using your services and looking to receive the environmental attributes—the greenness, or the electric nature of the service itself.
And so, one of the main takeaways here is that ZETc cannot just be issued on empty loads. It still requires that you are providing freight work for a customer, because that’s what’s really leading to the benefit to the environment, to the atmosphere, and into the transition to battery electric trucks. And so, what this means is you still need a metric to be able to allocate these empty legs to customers, whether that be loaded miles, TKM—which inherently includes payload into it—or loaded kilowatt-hours serviced to a customer.
So let’s look at an example. I think this is going to be helpful to make sure that we’re understanding what’s happening in this ecosystem for a carrier who is looking to provide physical shippers the ability to claim the emissions impact.
So in this example, you’ll have Shipper A going from the port to the Shipper A’s facility, let’s say. Shipper A is an organization that is not contributing to the decarbonization, is not necessarily partnering on the decarbonization or the electrification of this trucking route. And they’re not paying anything above traditional diesel rates. And they are eligible to be able to sell that certificate off of that route.
And then from there—let’s say this is a very illustrative, simplified example here—but let’s say they then have an empty load to go pick up another facility from Shipper C. And Shipper C in this example is partnering on the decarbonization. They are perhaps paying a slightly higher price, or perhaps they’ve changed their operations to be able to accommodate this. They’ve given some sort of long-term assurance, whatever it may be that they are providing. And they are providing business and providing a commercial structure to the carrier in return for also receiving the ability to claim the environmental attribute, or the electric nature of the services for their goods.
In this case, that green Shipper C is going to be receiving the attribute, but it’s going to be through the physical method, we would call it. So essentially, they are going to be able to just change their emissions intensity based off of the information that you as the carrier provide them. Whereas Shipper A in this instance would not be able to adjust their reporting. They would have to do their reporting as if it was on a diesel truck. And this is to be making sure that we are avoiding what we call erroneous double accounting.
And so in this example, what we need to do is we need to allocate the empty Leg B to both of these shippers. And this is following the GLEC Framework and the ISO standard that I mentioned as well. This is all part of that broader emissions accounting ecosystem.
And so in this case here, what we could do is we could use the kilowatt-hours and the loaded kilometers or loaded miles to help allocate that 50 kilowatt-hours to both of the legs. And so we would take the 166 kilowatt-hours, the 210 kilowatt-hours, and the 50 kilowatt-hours—so all the kilowatt-hours from this whole period. And then we would take the loaded kilometers, so this is only the 150 and the 200. So we have 200, excluding the 45 kilometers from that empty leg.
And essentially now we create an allocation approach to be able to say you went 200 kilometers, and therefore that actually constitutes 1.22 kilowatt-hours per loaded kilometer. So we slightly inflate the number of kilowatt-hours to each one of these different legs. And so in this case, what we’re doing is, we’re allocating that empty leg so that it’s not being issued inappropriately and against the standards ecosystem.
I’ll note here that you could also—again, this example only uses the loaded kilometers as the way of allocating that, but you could also do it on the loaded kilowatt-hours. Or if you were gathering TKM data, you could also do it directly on TKM, since that inherently includes payload and considers the empty leg as zero.
Just in terms of the issuance process, we talked about what data you need for being able to upload into and be able to generate a certificate. Talked a little bit about the allocation approach for empty loads if you are providing attributes to both physical customers and those unbundled ZETc.
And then what do you do with that? So you gather that data. You have that be verified by an approved body. More information on this will be provided during the RFP. But there’s a number of verifiers that are already well versed in the Smart Freight Centre ecosystem—so that MBM, as well as these GLEC and ISO standards that I mentioned.
And then with that verifier stamp of approval, that data is then uploaded into a registry. And so in the registry, there’s a number of different functions. You’ll have an upload document, a submission document, to be able to make sure that you have all the required fields fulfilled. There may be some conversions or data manipulation that happens in that. It’s obviously all very documented. And that is then what issues your ZETc.
From there, based off of the contracts that the carriers or the aggregator has, it will be transferred to each one of those buyers. They’ll have their own issuance and their own way of logging in to the registry. And then they’ll be able to claim those ZETc—essentially click a button that says that they would have retired them. And now they can make credible claims in their reporting and in their emissions accounting.
Here’s a very simple visual of what a registry retirements table looks like. You essentially see all the information for all the different certificates that a buyer may have, and then you can essentially allocate that on the back end.
So one of the key things in this ecosystem, as we look to transition the economy to electric assets, electric industry, we think that it’s really important to also be greening and decarbonizing our renewable energy sources, our energy power sources.
And so what that does is that reduces the charging emissions to be able to actually claim that lower well-to-wheel impact from electric trucking. It also helps support the greenness of the grid, and that helps build a more resilient electric system, as well as an even more insulated electric system from the changing of diesel and other kinds of fuel-based generation.
So really what the renewable energy is going to also reduce the price to some of the buyers in terms of the impact that they might have on their inventory accounting, as there’s some differences in relative price between renewable energy and switching to the battery electric trucking itself. So we see renewable energy as a really pivotal component to make sure that we are creating the kind of future that we want through this transition.
I just want to note quickly on some of the criteria for renewable energy. I’ll note beforehand that I recognize most on this call are probably not familiar with renewable energy procurement. Electrification of trucking is already a large enough challenge and a big enough opportunity to be able to really learn and work through this new way of doing transportation.
So with that in mind, we will also provide guidance on a number of the companies that can help facilitate this renewable energy procurement process. And you’re not necessarily needed to become an expert in renewable energy as well. There is a large industry that can help support in that. But I want to make sure that you all have the information to be able to just understand the concepts that will come into the procurement process that may be considered through the evaluation or the shortlisting in the contracting.
And so a few criteria of the renewable procurement process. One is the deliverability. So essentially, this is whether the energy—so let’s say a solar facility—whether that energy from that solar facility could actually be delivered to your charging facility where these trucks are. And so whether they’re on the same grid or the same region balancing authority. This is the concept of deliverability.
The second here is whether that renewable energy is bundled or unbundled. And what that means is that the renewable energy certificates are combined with your energy contract or separate completely. And so what a bundled renewable energy contract looks like is called a power purchase agreement, or a utility tariff, where essentially you’re negotiating with a new solar or wind facility, for example, or with your utility to be able to actually help receive those renewable energy certificates while you’re also paying for your utility bills.
Temporal matching is about how closely the renewable energy generation—so again, when is that solar plant actually creating the electrons, or the wind turning the turbine—and when you are dispensing that electricity into a vehicle. And so typically we see this spanning across annually, biannually, monthly, daily, hourly. There’s a whole spectrum of how close you can get with for temporal matching.
And the last one here is about additionality—what some call emissions first, or emissions and emissionality. This is a bit more nuanced and complex here. But the idea being: did the renewable energy help actually get a new facility, a new wind or solar, let’s say, up and running?
Again, our goal is not for you all to be full experts, especially after just one conversation here, but just to have a lay of the land. And so we’re still exploring some of these requirements for the next RFP.
But at this point, it’s trending towards the procurement requiring that we have some geographic matching when it’s possible, but not necessarily full same grid all the time.
And then for bundled and unbundled, we are open to unbundled, particularly for instances where you may be charging at a number of different chargers, or you maybe only have a handful or a couple chargers at a facility. That’s not enough scale to do a bundled PPA. And so in those instances, we likely will be open to having those unbundled RECs. For a deployment that does leverage a large—let’s say, a large-scale depot style, where you’re having 15, 20-plus chargers—that does often have the kind of power demand to be able to have a PPA. And so in those instances, we likely will prefer the best option, which is going to be that PPA. So if you’re exploring that, it’d be interesting to start those conversations as well.
And then lastly, on the temporal matching, we are likely going to have this sit in the middle, at annual matching. And that’s to be able to help with the claim of that these vehicles have supported renewable electricity in the same timeframe. Going all the way to hourly matching is untenable for this sector. But also there is a pretty liquid market for renewable energy options, as well as, again, a lot of development happening. And so we do think there’s likelihood to be able to find those 12-month opportunities.
One more topic before handing off to Stacey. So as I said, there’s a number of different ways to be able to get involved. There also are a number of different service organizations that can help with renewable energy. But it’s important to clarify here what different members of the ecosystem are responsible or able to do.
So for example, the CPO and the carrier are able to provide that charging data. That can then back how much renewable energy needs to be procured. The carrier is really the primary one to be able to provide the data on activity, to be able to do the allocation or to issue on that freight work.
The new thing within this is that there’s, again, for some more forthcoming standard guidance that will highlight that potentially a CPO, carrier, or a shipper could be able to procure RECs on behalf of the activity from the carrier. And so this is something new that we’re continuing to explore, of whether there’s an opportunity to help aggregate across and have other parties get involved.
And the last thing here is, everybody is responsible for helping to maintain that there’s not duplicative claims. So we want to avoid that, multiple parties are saying they’ve both implemented renewable energy, or they’ve all reduced the emissions from this battery electric trucking activity. That would be that erroneous double counting. And so there are roles for each of these players to make sure that we’re not having that kind of erroneous double counting.
OK, now with that, I will pause and turn over to Stacey to talk a little bit about the next procurement.
STACEY MCCLUSKEY:
Thanks, Clayton. So there are a couple other features related to the upcoming procurement that we want to highlight as well. A lot of these things are new to our second procurement, so if you responded to the pilot, these will be some differences to look out for.
The first is the introduction of the aggregator model. So this concept was introduced in the pilot, but not really used by any of the bidders. So we spent the past couple of months really fleshing it out to provide a little bit more guidance about what we expect it to look like. It will allow multiple carriers to respond under a single intermediary known as an aggregator, who will help the carriers with data management, validation, and certificate issuance. And I’ll get a little bit more into the details of what this actually means in a moment.
Also, in our pilot, we supported a single carrier deploying ZETs in one state. So for this next procurement, we really want to scale up, with the goal of working with more carriers across a range of states and geographies. So to this end, we’re really hoping to see bids from interstate routes, or looking for the ability to pick multiple bids in different geographies. We really think this is going to have a large impact in growing the market, getting more trucks on the road, and increasing the available infrastructure.
To the third point, many of you may be familiar with SFC and Catalyst Mobility’s ZET SCALE initiative, which we also touched on in the first webinar. So if you aren’t super familiar, I definitely recommend going back to that recording. But as a reminder, ZET SCALE has done a mapping of the top 10 hubs in the best routes for electrification based on incentives and infrastructure. So in our evaluation of bids, we will be looking for routes that overlap with this mapping. We see these as viable areas where book and claim demand can really bolster the economics of the ZET deployment.
Lastly, the pilot was primarily concerned with bids where 100% of the certificates generated went to our book and claim buyers. So as part of the second procurement, carriers can now choose how they want to split the allocation of their services between customers with physical demand and those with book and claim. So, for example, a carrier could choose to allocate 40% of the zero-emission services and certificates to physical customers, and the remaining 60% could go to book and claim buyers. Doing this does require the carrier to have a clear allocation model, so no double-counting activity occurs. Or, alternatively, carriers can continue to just sell 100% of the certificates to book and claim, consistent with the first procurement, if they wish.
So, going back to the aggregator model, we see this as a concept to really broaden carrier participation and help the market deploy ZETs faster and more efficiently. Essentially, under this model, there would be a central entity, such as a financier, a truck lessor, an LSP, infrastructure provider, or really any entity that’s going to serve as that intermediary and act as that aggregator.
An aggregator’s role is to really centralize the data management, validation, and certificate issuance. So, to this end, the aggregator is responsible for signing contracts on both sides of the issuance process. So, they’d be signing a contract with the buyers interested in purchasing the certificates, and then the carriers looking to sell. The aggregator would also manage the bidding process on behalf of the carriers, determining how many certificates to offer and at what price.
We do think that this model may be of specific interest to small and medium carriers, who may not have the time or the resources to bid on their own, and it will probably also help achieve deployment of more trucks over a geographic range, which is one of our goals in this procurement. We will be publishing more details on the aggregator model, including what it entails and other considerations, pretty shortly for any interested carriers or potential aggregators.
Before launching the RFP in early 2027, we are looking to get feedback and insight from carriers through our RFI, which is now live. So this RFI is designed to help GMA Trucking refine the structure of our next procurement and better understand carrier readiness, deployment opportunities, charging needs, and preferred commercial terms. So those responses will feed directly into how our upcoming procurement is shaped, so your responses really are important. You can find that RFI on our GMA website, and you have until December 4th to respond.
And lastly, before we get into Q&A, we have one more webinar in this series, and the date for that is December 15th at 1 p.m. Eastern. During that webinar, we’ll be diving deeper into additionality, allocation, and double counting, as well as contracting considerations. This will also be after the RFI closes, so we’re going to use it as an opportunity to address any frequently asked questions that we assess in our preliminary review of the results. So be sure to add that to your calendar.
And with that, we’re going to turn over to Q&A. So please use that Q&A functionality at the bottom of your screen to ask your questions. I know we already had a couple sent in, so we’ll get to those in a moment. And Jakob, Clayton, if you want to come on, we can start getting to that.
Okay. So just looking at these questions, the first one I’ll send to you, Clayton. Do trucks already delivered or ordered qualify, or are we only considering new deployments enabled by the offtake? Is there an in-service cut-off date to that point?
CLAYTON GERBER:
Awesome. Yeah, thanks for the question here. So somewhat similar to our first procurement, we are likely to enable both for new trucks that are fully not ordered yet, or perhaps on order but not yet delivered. Those would be, I’d say, preferred, in the sense that they are really new to the market. We’re helping to catalyze new deployment and new purchase of trucks.
But we do recognize that there may be instances of trucks that are currently purchased, maybe either waiting to be deployed or operating to a small extent, but are not meeting the expectations that were provided when the investment was made. And so we are open to considering purchasing ZETc from trucks that are in operations. But we will want to see some additional justification for why ZETc is needed in that case, because obviously the business case was established enough to make the investment. And so there needs to be some reason why ZETc is still catalytic to making the next investment, or to utilizing these trucks and avoiding the next emissions from a diesel truck. So I hope that answers the question.
STACEY MCCLUSKEY:
This next question I’ll send to you, Jakob. Does the freight service being displaced need to already exist, or can a new route, where diesel would be the likely baseline, serve as the counterfactual?
JAKOB SANCHEZ:
Yes. So it could be either. We would anticipate, regardless of which pathway the actual ZETc ends up being issued on, that it could displace actual diesel carrier-specific routing information. We might consider that to be the highest-fidelity pathway. However, of course, it isn’t going to be operationally feasible for all carriers.
So in the event that a carrier can’t provide their own counterfactual information, we will be enabling and facilitating a process by which to use highly conservative defaults by which they can compare that service to, or the energy-based pathway. The issuance is going to look slightly different, and how we actually arrive at the ultimate functional unit that the certificate is issued on, than with the traditional TKM freight work-based calculation pathway. But that information will be handled by the registry, and by the actual buyers in their certificates. And our carriers aren’t going to need to be super concerned about that. But yes, it can be either. And in the event that there isn’t primary data, default data will be enabled.
CLAYTON GERBER:
And maybe one thing I’ll add to that as well. The part of, I think, this question also—if it was asked in the context of how are you finding, as a carrier, those physical routes—it gets to some of that criteria that Jakob talked to at the beginning of the presentation today, of providing assurance and how you’re going to be able to source those routes, right? These trucks are only issuing certificates when they’re being used for customers.
And so this could be you have existing customers in a region and you’re already operating routes with a diesel truck, and you’re just swapping out that diesel truck for a battery electric truck. But it also could be that you’re perhaps entering a market, a new market, or you’re expanding your fleet with battery electric trucks, and that will require that you find new customers. And as long as you have a plan to be able to do that, and how you have confidence—why you have confidence that you’ll be able to win that business enabled and aided by the certificates—that can be sufficient as well. But we’ll want to be able to gather information. There will be questions in the RFP to understand your plan for how you will get that business.
STACEY MCCLUSKEY:
Thank you both. Clayton, I’ll stick with you. So can trucks in the program also earn state clean fuel credits, such as the California LCFS, or have received purchase incentives like HVIP, without affecting eligibility or the ZETc value?
CLAYTON GERBER:
Yeah, another great question. I’ll note that we will talk more about this in the next webinar when we talk about additionality. We’ll get into some of the weeds around the different policy implications, etc.
At a high level, the current stance is that you would be able to receive both of those kinds of incentives. And so that’s both grants as well as opt-in programs like an LCFS. There are certain regulations that would have impacted more—namely, like the ACF, for example, is more of a requirement to take action. And that in some instances would have the Advanced Clean Fleet. But that was repealed, so it’s not currently in practice.
The other thing I would note, to your last point around affecting eligibility of the ZETc or the value itself: we’ll still likely ask a question of why is ZETc important? Why do you need ZETc to be able to justify the deployment or the use of these trucks? In line with what I was mentioning earlier, for trucks that are already operating, if trucks are already operating for several years, are meeting all the expectations that they had when they made the investment, perhaps utilized grants to make that investment, there isn’t really a need, we don’t think, for ZETc to help that instance. And we want to help direct the ZETc where they’re going to be the most catalytic.
So we’ll still ask, no matter what, even if receiving those kinds of grants, that you justify why the ZETc is needed. It would not disqualify, though, to be receiving grants. We still think that these instruments can be complementary to other kinds of regulatory incentive programs.
STACEY MCCLUSKEY:
Thank you. Jakob, is it possible for you to share the ZETc price range or an average price range from the last procurement so we can benchmark our bids?
JAKOB SANCHEZ:
Unfortunately, we are not able to share pricing information. We are subject to quite strict antitrust laws, so at this time, we cannot offer numerical ranges. However, when it comes to actually pricing your ZETc bid, in general, we’re going to want to anchor that to the cost for actually operating the electric versus traditional diesel, what’s often referred to as the green premium, any costs of infrastructure, and the risk that might be associated with deploying this new kind of technology. Anything you might add to that, Clayton?
CLAYTON GERBER:
I don’t think so. We’ll provide some more information on this. But generally, yeah, we can’t share, just as an intermediary in this space. We can’t be seen as price-fixing and setting the price for the market. And that’s why we go to the competitive bid process, to be able to help the market itself establish that price, as opposed to us anchoring too much. And so we don’t share a numerical number.
You are free to look at other kinds of commodities in this space. You’re also able to look at, again, as Jakob said, what are your requirements? Really, the goal is here, like, what do you need to be able to make this investment? There’s a number of different ways that carriers could go about answering that question. And really, the competitive process is just to help identify, like, what is that minimum that you need, above which, you’d be just taking profit, which is obviously inefficient for the market, but below which you would not make the investment. That’s the area that we want to be able to identify and help incentivize the market to create that competitive ecosystem.
STACEY MCCLUSKEY:
And then we have a couple questions asking about when we plan on releasing the next RFP, and when we have a projected due date for that. So Clayton, do you want to answer that for us?
CLAYTON GERBER:
Yeah, absolutely. I think we touched on this in the first webinar, but happy to do so again, and we can reiterate it in the third one.
So we are going through the RFI period now, which, as mentioned, will close in December. We’ll take that information and help inform the development of the RFP, as well as continue gathering our demand, and we’re looking to launch the RFP in March, maybe early April, to be able to then have carriers respond. It’ll likely be open for roughly a two-month period, and then at which point we’ll evaluate the bids, move to the shortlisting, and then selection and contracting.
We hope, since this is now our second iteration and we just went through this last year, we’ll have a lot of the muscle and infrastructure from a contracting perspective to be able to hopefully move a little faster through that process. It’s still likely that we would be contracting in end of Q2, Q3 area, given the lead time to be able to respond, and then go through that selection process.
STACEY MCCLUSKEY:
We have a question related to the aggregator model. This was submitted before we answered or talked about that model. But, Jakob, is there anything you want to add or touch on related to ZETc price, handling of data, emissions calculation, or verification that I might have glossed over when I was discussing that earlier?
JAKOB SANCHEZ:
Anything worth saying is worth repeating. So I think we see this aggregator model as offering a really elegant solution for greater participation. We would also love to see the economy of scale that an aggregator or larger bid might offer to the overall pricing. In general, we want to see prices reduced. This will only serve to make the market more liquid and improve buyer appetite for the actual attributes themselves.
The aggregator is just one potential pathway that might achieve that ultimate goal, with all those added benefits, Stacey, that you already walked through related to data management. So if one sophisticated intermediary can go about the process of gathering the data from their carriers, submitting it for verification, and contracting directly with the buyers, that’ll make it much easier for carriers to participate and still have the benefit of an EAC offtake without some of the administrative burden and upskilling that is required to participate in these markets, because of the data that is needed, because of the verification that is required.
And on our buyer side, it will make one intermediary with which they need to interface, which could serve to improve demand and make the whole process even that much more attractive for a member buyer that wants to participate and doesn’t necessarily want to contract with a large portfolio of carriers.
STACEY MCCLUSKEY:
Clayton, I’m going to send a couple your way. I’ll read them one at a time, though. So for the next RFP, is there any guidance on the potential size of the opportunity?
CLAYTON GERBER:
Yeah, absolutely. So we are looking—and I’ll highlight a couple different points here. So we are looking in the realm of two to four hundred trucks is what we’re targeting. So it’s pretty significant increase from the first procurement.
Now, part of that will also vary based off of whether those trucks are planning on providing attributes to physical customers as well as issuing these ZETc, right? Because then one truck would then potentially only be issuing a portion of ZETc, and therefore we might need more trucks to be able to reach that volume. So part of this will depend upon exactly the carrier preference and structure for issuance, as well as, of course, the pricing. But generally we are looking for it in the hundreds range of trucks in this procurement.
And then I’ll also note that while the first RFP and procurement process was one carrier in one location, we do— part of the impetus for the aggregator model and interest in the aggregator model. But even broader than that, we are looking to have multiple geographies represented and multiple carriers represented. We don’t want this to just be like, it’s just only one location, or we just pick one. But rather, we want to help support the market, from the bottom, and have multiple carriers and likely multiple regions as well.
STACEY MCCLUSKEY:
And just to add to that geography point, we are looking exclusively in the U.S. for this procurement. But that’s not to say that future procurements might not be looking outside of the U.S. and in other countries or regions.
Clayton, sticking with you. My understanding is that ZETc attributes will be priced differently based on where the carrier is deploying and generating. In that case, how will the bidding process take into account multi-regional deployment? For example, deploying in Texas is going to cost differently from deploying in New York.
CLAYTON GERBER:
Yeah, absolutely. So this is one of the functions and value of the book and claim system, is that it provides flexibility for organizations to be able to support deployment of trucks in a range of different locations. Many of our shipper members have activity across the U.S., or in different regions. But also, the idea is that we can, by supporting deployment of these trucks even in one location, we’re still actually really bolstering the market altogether, right? We’re showing demand for these electric trucks, which will in turn help get more OEMs involved, increase competition, which would lower prices, etc.
So all in all, we do recognize that there will be differently priced bids likely in different regions, based off of electricity costs, incentives, etc. And that is part of the process. At this point, we are likely to remain pretty flexible in terms of the different bids, and want to find those that are the most cost competitive. That’s where we are, early stage in this market.
Over time and in subsequent procurements, we may end up focusing on certain regions, or requiring distribution across certain regions. But at this point, we’re still early enough in the zero-emission and the battery electric truck deployment ecosystem that we don’t want to impose that kind of restrictions on this procurement. So all in all, yes, there will be some potentially differently priced opportunities across different regions. But we are at this point are going to be largely open to any of those.
STACEY MCCLUSKEY:
A couple more questions. I know we’re getting close on time. So, Jakob, do you need to respond to the RFI in order to respond to the RFP?
JAKOB SANCHEZ:
No. RFI is completely voluntary and will help shape the ultimate structure of the RFP. So if you would like to influence some of the design considerations of that, please, we would highly encourage submission for the RFI. But participation in the RFP does not predicate on that participation in the RFI.
STACEY MCCLUSKEY:
Okay. I think we have time for one more question. So: understanding the constraints, would looking at a price per pound of carbon give an indication of potential value? Clayton, I’ll go to you for that one.
CLAYTON GERBER:
Yeah. I mean, definitely that is one way of thinking about price. So among all of those, again, as we mentioned, like, you could look at the TCO, you could look at, like, what you need in terms of your freight rate to be able to win business in that market. And also you could try to calculate something like that to be able to have benchmarks in other sectors and other activities. So all of those are ways to create benchmarks.
Again, ultimately, it’s going to be up to the carrier, and wanting to be able to be competitive in this ecosystem. The primary goal here is to be able to price such that you will make the investment, right? If you’ll make the investment today, and you’ll be able to operate these trucks without any additional revenue from ZETc, transparently, that’s not necessarily where we want to focus our activity. So we do still want ZETc to help deployment of these trucks. But to help guide what price you might be able to leverage or benchmark, there’s a number of those different tools, that being one of them.
With that, I know we’re out of time, so I’m happy to wrap us up here. So thank you all for the questions, for the engagement. Please keep them coming. If you have any outstanding questions, feel free to message one of us or respond to the emails that we send after this webinar.
Again, we will have the third one mid-December. And just before that, on December 4th, the RFI will be due. We really, really appreciate you all taking the time. If you have the capacity to be able to respond to the RFI, even in a partial form, please, please do so. It really helps us so we can actually design this procurement process effectively. If you’d rather have a 30-minute call or something to be able to provide feedback, we can be open to that as well. But providing that RFI document is going to be the most effective, most streamlined way to make sure that your preferences are considered and heard in the upcoming procurement process.
So thank you all. Appreciate it. Have a great rest of the week. And we will talk again soon.